The Enduring Mystery of Mistie Murray

 

The Enduring Mystery of Mistie Murray


On a warm spring evening in May 1995, 16-year-old Mistie Murray stepped out of her dance class in the quiet town of Goderich, Ontario—and vanished into the night. No footsteps, no witnesses, no trace. What happened next would shatter a family, stun a close-knit community, and leave a mystery that has defied answers for nearly three decades.

In this pulse-pounding episode of Ontario Cold Cases - Canada’s True Crime Podcast, host Jay Nicoll, founder of Nicoll Investigations, plunges into the haunting disappearance that still echoes through the streets of Goderich. With razor-sharp expertise, Jay reconstructs that fateful day: the last sighting in the town square, the desperate searches along Lake Huron’s shores, and the chilling suspicion that fell on Mistie’s stepfather, Steven Murray. A trial gripped the nation—yet an acquittal left the case dangling in shadow, with no body, no evidence, and a truth that refuses to surface.

Was Mistie snatched by a stranger lurking in the twilight? Did she stumble into a tragic accident, swallowed by the lake or the woods? Or does the key lie closer to home, buried in secrets yet untold? As Jay unravels the theories and confronts the emotional wreckage left behind, one question burns: What really happened to Mistie Murray?

Join Ontario Cold Cases as we peel back the layers of this decades-old enigma, inviting you—the listener—to help crack a case that’s haunted Canada since 1995. Tune in, dig deep, and be part of the search for justice. Because Mistie’s story isn’t over—and the truth is still out there, waiting to be found.

Because every case deserves answers—and every victim deserves justice.

Subscribe now to Ontario Cold Cases: Canada’s True Crime Podcast. Episodes available wherever you get your podcasts.

Follow us for updates and more: @OntarioColdCases

Ontario Cold Cases - Wordpress
https://nicollinvestigations.wordpress.com/

Ontario Cold Cases - Substack
https://substack.com/@ontariocoldcase

For more videos subscribe to: https://www.youtube.com/@OntarioColdCases?sub_confirmation=1

@PlayMorePods

#OntarioColdCases, #NicollInvestigations , #canadiancrime , #ColdCasePodcast , #ontariocrime, #OntarioMysteries , #PodcastMystery , #truecrimepodcast , #unsolvedmysteries, #ontario, #TrueCrimeCanada, #TrueCrimeOntario, #CanadianMysteries, #canada,  #truecrime, #PodcastsOnAmazonMusic, #Murder, #Homicide, #Missing, #ColdCases, #MistieMurray, #Goderich,

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Missing Ontario Man Last Seen at Popular Quebec Ski Village in 2025! Whe...

Image
  WHERE IS LIAM GABRIEL TOMAN? Missing since February 2, 2025 after leaving a local après ski bistro in the Village of Mont Tremblant, Quebec     The family of Liam Toman is urgently appealing to the media and public to help in the on-going search of this young Ontario man, who vanished on a group ski trip on February 2nd and has still not been found. Ontario Cold Cases: Canada’s True Crime Podcast. Subscribe today on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows to stay updated on cold cases that continue to demand answers. Ontario Cold Cases - Wordpress https://nicollinvestigations.wordpress.com/ Ontario Cold Cases - Substack https://substack.com/@ontariocoldcase For more videos subscribe to: https://www.youtube.com/@OntarioColdCases?sub_confirmation=1 @PlayMorePods #OntarioColdCases, #NicollInvestigations , #canadiancrime , #ColdCasePodcast , #ontariocrime, #OntarioMysteries , #PodcastMystery , #truecrimepodcast , #unsolvedmysteries, #ontario,...
Read more

Ontario Cold Cases - Special Edition: Rinse ’N’ Repeat | Patreon

Image
Ontario Cold Cases - Special Edition: Rinse ’N’ Repeat | Patreon   Home invasions, homicide, car theft show need for bail reform - Toronto Sun Less than a year after bail reform tinkering, Canada's premiers tell Trudeau he hasn't gone far enough. Terms like bail and probation don’t mean much these days, not in Justin Trudeau’s catch-and-release justice system. A horrific homicide in British Columbia and a car-theft ring in Ontario may not seem related, but on this front they are. Thank you, and please consider subscribing to Ontario Cold Cases – The Podcast available wherever you listen to your favourite podcasts. Ontario Cold Cases - Wordpress https://nicollinvestigations.wordpress.com/ @PlayMorePods #OntarioColdCases, #NicollInvestigations , #canadiancrime , #ColdCasePodcast , #ontariocrime, #OntarioMysteries , #PodcastMystery , #serialkiller , #truecrimepodcast , #unsolvedmysteries, #ontario, #TrueCrimeCanada, #TrueCrimeOntario, #CanadianMysteries, #canada, #coldcase, #missi...
Read more

Where is Doris Fennell and Was She Murdered? | Patreon

Image
Where is Doris Fennell and Was She Murdered? | Patreon   Ontario Cold Cases - The Podcast: Missing Person: Doris Fennell Doris Fennell was last observed at the home of an acquaintance in Kitley-Elizabeth Township, near Addison, Ontario on February 1, 1978. Foul Play is strongly suspected in her disappearance. Doris was 62 years old at the time of her disappearance. She had grey, short, permed hair and blue eyes Doris wore glass and had false teeth. She was 5’3” and weighed 110 pounds with a slender to thin build and a fair complexion. If you have any information on this case, please contact any of the following: Leeds County OPP at 1-877-934-6363 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS Thank you, and please consider subscribing to Ontario Cold Cases – The Podcast on Patreon, Spotify, YouTube , Apple Podcasts, iHeartRadio or Amazon Music. Patreon - https://patreon.com/user?u=22757519&utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator&utm_cont...
Read more